Home » News » Currently Reading:

Healthcare Informatics 7/17/12

July 17, 2012 News 1 Comment

Healthcare Infrastructure Data Models
Option 3 — Health Record Banks

Option 1: The Centralized Repository is described here.
Option 2: The Federated Model is described here.

Think Google Health or Microsoft HealthVault with an actual business plan. The patient controls access to their data and pushes it or allows it to be pulled at their request. Admittedly, I hadn’t heard of this concept until the founder of the Health Record Bank Alliance told me about it, so I can’t say this model is just around the proverbial corner.

When we philosophize from our arm chairs about how healthcare should be, one particular theme always bubbles up: the patient should control their health and their health information. But have we accomplished that, even with the concept of a Patient-Centered Medical Home?

Right now, our healthcare system is centralized. This means that if we go to a well-organized institution, our information and services will center around us as long as we don’t leave. But if the industry follows the disruptive innovation pathway laid out by Clayton Christensen in The Innovator’s Prescription, we will eventually arrive at a decentralized model of healthcare. That means the hospital-centered healthcare will become passé. It also means we need to find a way to deliver patient health information to the practitioner on demand. As in, it is stored with the patient, not the provider.

Personal Health Records (PHRs) would seem to be the obvious solution to this. Due to a lack of record portability and motivation, they have turned out to be duds even to data geeks like myself. I once logged every time I picked at my fingernails and what I was thinking about at the time in order to figure out how to break the habit (willingly), but I logged into my Google Health account (RIP) exactly twice.

The portability issue will be resolved, and thank Meaningful Use for that. Motivation, though? Most of us don’t actively track our health status. We wake up, we subconsciously determine whether we have it in us to survive the day, and then we get moving. A Health Record Bank could potentially provide motivation in the form of payment opportunities.

Let’s say you received a micropayment every time an organization queried your health record for research, public health assessment, or even marketing information. Not enough revenue to generate a career, but it could buy you coffee every now and then. All you’d have to do is maintain your record like you do your checking account. Would that be something you’d be interested in?

Record portability? Yes. Public Health assessment? Yes, with payment. Consider it an incentive payment going to the right people.

Given these three models — the centralized repository, the federated query, and the health record bank — which is the one that will be used moving forward? Even though the proponents of these models act like they are competing models, are they not complimentary in some fashion? Centralized repositories are great for in-depth analysis once the data is actually gathered. Federated queries are good for a small network to share data. Health record banks motivate the originator of information (the patient) to give up the data and spread it in addition to establishing ownership.

An EHR in the hands of the majority is the first step to setting down this path, where these models can interact. But make no mistake, it is not the last. Eventually, EHRs will become the processing tools to send information for expert analysis, not from which to extract information.

Aaron Berdofe is an independent health information technology contractor specializing in Meditech’s Medical and Practice Management Suite and EHR design and development.

Comments 1
  • “Give me Liberty, or Give me Death!” – Patrick Henry

    What a brilliant ruling by the United States Supreme Court on the affordable health care act (Obamacare). Stunningly brilliant in my humble opinion. I could not have ask for a better ruling on a potentially catastrophic healthcare act than We The People Of The United States received from our Supreme Court.

    If the court had upheld the constitutionality of the individual mandate under the commerce clause it would have meant the catastrophic loss of the most precious thing we own. Our individual liberty. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! Supreme Court.

    There is no mandate to buy private for-profit health insurance. There is only a nominal tax on income eligible individuals who don’t have health insurance. This is a HUGE! difference. And I suspect that tax may be subject to constitutional challenge as it ripens.

    This is a critically important distinction. Because under the commerce clause individuals would have been compelled to support the most costly, dangerous, unethical, morally repugnant, and defective type of health insurance you can have. For-profit health insurance, and the for-profit proxies called private non-profits and co-ops.

    Equally impressive in the courts ruling was the majorities willingness to throw out the whole law if the court could not find a way to sever the individual mandate under the commerce clause from the rest of the act. Bravo! Supreme Court.

    Thanks to the Supreme Court we now have an opportunity to fix our healthcare crisis the right way. Without the obscene delusion that Washington can get away with forcing Americans to buy a costly, dangerous and highly defective private product (for-profit health insurance).

    During the passage of ACA/Obamacare some politicians said that the ACA was better than nothing. But the truth was that until the Supreme Court fixed it the ACA/Obamacare was worse than nothing at all. It would have meant the catastrophic loss of your precious liberty for the false promise and illusion of healthcare security under the deadly and costly for-profit healthcare system that dominates American healthcare.

    As everyone knows now. The fix for our healthcare crisis is a single payer system (Medicare for all) like the rest of the developed world has. Or a robust Public Option choice available to everyone on day one that can quickly lead to a single payer system.

    We still have a healthcare crisis in America. With hundreds of thousands dieing needlessly every year in America. And a for-profit medical industrial complex that threatens the security and health of the entire world. The ACA/Obamacare will not fix that.

    The for-profit medical industrial complex has already attacked the world with H1N1 killing thousands, and injuring millions. And more attacks are planned for profit, and to feed their greed.

    To all of you who have fought so hard to do the kind and right thing for your fellow human beings at a time of our greatest needs I applaud you. Be proud of your-self.

    God Bless You my fellow human beings. I’m proud to be one of you. You did good.

    See you on the battle field.


    jacksmith – WorkingClass 🙂

Comments are closed.

Platinum Sponsors




Gold Sponsors


Subscribe to Updates

Search All HIStalk Sites


Recent Comments

  1. Re: Walmart Health: Just had a great dental visit this morning, which was preceded by helpful reminders from Epic, and…

  2. NextGen announcement on Rusty makes me wonder why he was asked to leave abruptly. Knowing him, I can think of…

  3. "New Haven, CT-based medical billing and patient communications startup Inbox Health..." What you're literally saying here is that the firm…

  4. RE: Josephine County Public Health department in Oregon administer COVID-19 vaccines to fellow stranded motorists. "Hey, you guys over there…

  5. United is regularly referred to as "The Evil Empire" in the independent pediatric space (where I live). They are the…